Thoughts

Oct 24 1999  | Views 3235 |  Comments  (24)
... Expand

Leave a Comment   Flat Nested


  dirty_harry posted 6 yrs ago

What was the point of the story? OK, so you had a crush on some vagueall female in some vagueall gult restaurant...grow up boy!!



  AA posted 6 yrs ago

The article/story was good, especially, the way the author puts his feelings in words. Also, the whole thing where he describes his parents' reaction etc seems very realistic. All this leads me to believe that this might have been a real life experience. If that is the case, he should express his feelings to the girl. For if he does not he will never know for himself what might have happened if he had confessed. The worst thing in life is having regrets abt what was/was not done. If the person has such intense feelings for this girl, the only way out would be to have a closure on the whole thing. Either it will work out for him with the girl or it wont but he would have atleast tried and not have to deal with regretting his timidity later. As to the issue of caste, approval from parents, etc, one has to decide for themselves what takes priority.. love or acceptance by family, both are big issues, and have different implications but its upto an individual to decide which is more important.



  Sonali Kolhatkar posted 9 yrs ago

Matters of the heart change lives. Strangely the guy described in the story turned his own life topsy turvy before having made a connection with the one he professed to love. I don't know if it's just me but is the author perhaps making a statement about the ludicriousness of the situation he describes in his story, a situation all too common among Indian men (and perhaps women, I'm not sure)? It brought to light the fact that it really is time to break away from worries that are no longer relevant in today's world, such as caste, parental permission, etc.

Sonali Kolhatkar



  Sagarika posted 9 yrs ago

To "Ashish" who lost his heart at "Mythri":

"Life is strewn with choices,
You make one, your own.
Listen to your heart's voices,
All the rest, you disown!"

-Sagarika.



  Suspicious Saravannan posted 9 yrs ago

I suspect all this charade of an article posted on sulekha.com to merely be a mask for Ashish's inability to actually express his feeling's towards that particular waitress gal at Mythri. Now, what this will serve is to somehow through this extensive desi grapevine reach this info to the kudi in question. Wah! Kya teer mara rey Ashish!! And it is a moot question now if the girl will know from reading this story who this Ashiq..sorry Ashish is! :)

Congratulations on your chicken heart Mr. Ashish.

SS.



  Sreenivas Durbha posted 9 yrs ago

Hi Aravind,
Althogh this article was successful in putting forth the perspective of a stereo-typical ABIY (America Bred Indian Yuppie), it is purely a question of personal conviction that will make or break a guy like Ashish's heart.
It is true that as much as we would not like to believe, we still have the bonding and respect towards our families back home. This will put us in a jeopardy. Being what we are, it is hard for us to totally go against our parents. Also the machinations of a heart in love are hard to contain. Caught between two ends we are in a state of limbo. That I believe is the reason for the tears that Ashish had shed. It is heart rending to not be able to decide between the family, the culture and life-style (a.k.a caste) that we were born into and brought up in, and the all powerful influence of Cupid.
At this juncture only a decisive mind w/ a strong personal conviction about one or the other belief about the ways of marrying can, in my opinion, be successful in deciding the future of one's life. If a family that you oh so dearly loved could think of counterposing your idea of marrying a girl of your choice (that by informing them in advance), you are forced to consider all the respect and the faith you had in the family entity. Parents being elderly command respect because of their parenthood and not because of their uppitiness or their beliefs steeped in tradition and sometimes ignorance.
When it is easy for them to scare an innocent child caught in a web of indecision and confusion, by talking of severing ties w/ him (possibly aggravating his hardship), it should force the child to consider something similar although it will be immensely hard on him. Now, if Ashish does not have the stomach to go talk to the girl all his tears are ill founded. It is just not him for such a situation. On the other hand, the love for the girl might reach him to a stage where it will only be natural for him to go talk to her.
My myriad "thoughts" about Ashish's thoughts.
Thank you.
Sreenivas.



  Neela Gollapudi posted 9 yrs ago

The story is well written with a simple flow, and gives the impression of being true. But perhaps not..

For the moment, taking the story to be true, or for all such true stories out there --

I have seen many a friend in this position. Although I don't like to trespass on Dr. Ro territory here :),
1)The first problem is the enormous build up. If there is an enormous build up, any break or disappointment becomes harder to handle. So, the sooner the issue is settled, one way or other, the better it is for the protagonist.
2)After all there may indeed be no caste problem. One has to find out before one worries oneself to death.
3)The caste problem, if it exists, becomes relavant, only if the girl is also interested. Maybe she is married :). One has no way of knowing unless one asks. See: "Girl in the train" by Chitral Kumar, on this site, for a beautiful story on this.
4)Now coming to the issue of rejection .. I have broken with many a poor soul on this :). The issue is quite simple. Either the girl is all that you believe that she is, or she isn't. Suppose she is, and suppose she rejects you, then trust her judgement that she is incompatible for you and look elsewhere. Suppose she calls you names and walks away in a huff, then do some Bayesian learning that your judgement of the girl is flawed, because she is unable to recognize the gem of a guy that you are, and in retrospect, you may as well not be interested in her.
5)Now this caste, shaste, and all that is complex and you have to figure out if you have what it takes to handle it. This 5th point does not admit trivial solutions, so I'll leave it here.

That is the 5 step path. It is not just theory -- has been put in practise.



  Neela G posted 9 yrs ago

Errata..

In my comment below, the word "broken" should read as "spoken"



  John Juan De Marco posted 9 yrs ago

Ashish should be practical about life and move on. He shouldn't hold on to one thing like a child. Its like working at some place and fearing to ask your boss for a raise. If you don't ask for a raise, you won't get it. Also, he is fearing failure. One should always accept failure gracefully. If you live life considering that now is the chance or never you will act and get results. Results will make you either happy or sad. Both, according to me, are temporary. Its how you act in these situations that make you "you". Successful people are not the people who always make right decisions, but they are people who always make their decissions right. Its upto you how you take things and its your choice whether to accept things and be happy or stick to one thing and be sad. Moving stone gathers no moss..



  RBR posted 9 yrs ago

My thundering applause and votes go to Mr. Ghai and Mr. Prabhakar's comments. Methinks Satya's prescription is based on his own m.o. w/ Sangeeta and in fact this may be common practice among many guys out there because in retrospect this is exaclty what my own hubby seems to have done.

A note to Mr. Chandrasekhar and Dr. Gollapudi: only when a situation is posted under MOH it becomes Dr. Ro's territory, not otherwise. In this particular case (Ashish's), Doc Ro tells me that it'd be an interesting MOH case to tackle as most of her cases are damsels in distress although, ahem, surreptitiously guys seek her advice via personal e-mail:-)

Cheers.

Rohini.





Leave a comment

Use rich text editor:


Santa Clara, Female
Member Since Oct 24 1999
© 1998-2008 Copyright Sulekha.com Connecting Indians Worldwide, All Rights Reserved.